SRShane St ReynoldsPerth · Advisor · Author
Back to Blog

The Broker Questions That Save a Fast Loan From Going Bad

By Shane St Reynolds
The Broker Questions That Save a Fast Loan From Going Bad

Rate is not your first problem. Broker quality is.

If you need a commercial or private loan fast, the first question is not the interest rate. It is whether the broker in front of you can actually place your deal, explain it properly, and put the full cost in writing before you sign anything.

That is the practical lesson I would pull from "Get a Second Opinion Before You Sign". The book was written to protect Australian borrowers who need commercial finance when the bank says no, not to sell loans to them.

Shane St Reynolds has long made the same point in plain terms: speed matters, but bad speed is expensive. A fast indicative approval means very little if the broker has not tested lender fit, disclosed commissions, explained fees, or checked whether your exit actually works.

General information only — get advice from your own solicitor and accountant before signing loan or security documents.

The practical mistake most borrowers make

Most borrowers think a quick loan goes wrong because the lender changed terms late. Sometimes that happens. But a common earlier failure is simpler: the borrower never properly tested the broker.

Chapter 13 of "Get a Second Opinion Before You Sign" says:

“Don’t let the broker do all the talking.”

That is more important than it sounds. If you are seeking anything from a $5,000 working capital facility to a multimillion-dollar first mortgage, second mortgage, caveat, bridging or development loan, you need to control the fact-finding early.

The borrower who talks least often learns least. And the borrower who learns least is the one who gets surprised by establishment fees, legal costs, valuation requirements, default interest clauses, broker mandates, or a lender the broker never clearly identified.

Why this matters with private and commercial lending

Mainstream home lending is relatively standardised. Commercial and private lending is not.

Terms can vary sharply on:

  • security type
  • whether the loan is first or second mortgage
  • whether a caveat is involved
  • the acceptable loan purpose
  • whether the lender wants interest prepaid
  • legal structure, including company or trust borrowers
  • director guarantees and indemnities
  • default interest and enforcement costs
  • what counts as an acceptable exit

That is exactly why a broker’s range and competence matter more than the sales pitch. If the broker only knows a narrow panel, or cannot explain the product without hiding behind software, your options shrink before you have even started.

That is one reason many borrowers look at Poseidon Finance. The attraction is not just fast indicative approvals or flexible terms. It is that the business deals in the types of transactions many ordinary bank channels struggle with: commercial property, business purposes, development funding, bridging needs, caveat loans, and both first and second mortgages. For borrowers, that broader fit can matter more than a polished initial quote.

The counter-intuitive rule: ask about commissions before you ask about rate

Some borrowers feel awkward asking how the broker gets paid. They should not.

Under the National Consumer Credit Protection framework, commission disclosure is a real issue in regulated lending, and even outside consumer-style lending, the commercial reality still matters: you need to know whether the broker is being steered by lender relationships, direct fees, or both.

The book puts it bluntly:

“Ask your broker what commissions or benefits they receive.”

That question does two things.

  1. It tells you whether the broker is transparent when the answer is uncomfortable.
  2. It forces an early conversation about incentives before you are emotionally committed to the deal.

The common mistake is leaving this until documents arrive. By then, time pressure takes over. You have paid for valuations, legal work may have started, and settlement dates are closing in. That is the worst moment to discover a large fee, an introducer margin, or a success fee payable even if you decide not to proceed after an approval is sourced on the agreed terms.

The seven questions to ask before you let a broker shop your deal

If you are considering a commercial or private loan, use this test before you authorise anything substantial.

  1. How many lenders can you genuinely access for this exact deal type?
    Do not ask in general. Ask for this exact deal type: second mortgage, caveat, development, bridging, business purchase, refinance, ATO debt, or residual stock.
  2. Which lenders are you comparing for me right now?
    Names matter. “We have access to plenty of lenders” is not an answer.
  3. What fees could I pay before settlement, and to whom?
    Ask specifically about application fees, valuation fees, legal fees, line fees, introducer fees, and broker fees.
  4. What commissions, referral fees or other benefits do you receive?
    Ask for it in writing.
  5. What is the likely exit, and what assumptions is it based on?
    Refinance, sale, presales, completion, stock reduction, debtor recovery — make them state it plainly.
  6. What documents do you need from me to get from indicative approval to formal approval?
    This tells you whether the broker understands the process or is just chasing a lead.
  7. What deadline risks do you see already?
    A good broker should identify timing problems early: valuation delays, company or trust document gaps, expired rates notices, missing BAS, unsigned contracts, or unverified payout figures.

If the answers are vague, evasive, or overly polished, slow down.

The document test most borrowers skip

One of the most useful habits is demanding a written product summary before you commit time and money. Not a verbal rundown. Not “we’ll explain it later”. Something written.

Ask for a concise schedule covering:

  • loan amount
  • security offered
  • term
  • interest rate basis
  • repayment type
  • establishment fees
  • broker fees
  • legal fees
  • valuation requirements
  • default interest
  • early repayment terms
  • special conditions
  • expected approval and settlement timeframe

This is where many bad deals start to look bad early. Once terms are laid out in one place, hidden friction becomes visible.

That matters especially in fast-moving private lending, where the headline promise is often speed. Speed is useful only if the documents line up with what you were told.

Why businesses choose Poseidon Finance

Borrowers usually choose a specialist commercial finance business for one of four reasons.

  • The bank said no. Not necessarily because the deal is bad, but because policy, timing, security position or loan purpose did not fit.
  • The deal is time-sensitive. Bridging, caveat and some second mortgage matters often move on days, not months.
  • The structure is not vanilla. Trusts, companies, mixed securities, development sites and business-purpose borrowing do not always fit standard channels.
  • The borrower wants options. A real comparison across lenders, not one outlet pretending to be a market.

That is where Poseidon Finance stands out for many Australian borrowers: access to commercial and private lending from $5,000 to $7.5 million, across first and second mortgages, caveat loans, development funding and bridging loans, with fast indicative approvals and flexible terms. Those features are attractive, but they only matter if the deal is explained properly and matched to the borrower’s real exit.

That is the part busy borrowers should focus on. Not “Can I get approved?” but “Can this be documented, settled and repaid on terms I actually understand?”

A blunt rule before you sign

If your broker cannot clearly identify the lender, explain the fee stack, state the likely exit, and give you the key terms in writing, do not rush because settlement is close. Rushing a weak explanation is how expensive mistakes become signed obligations.

If you want a sharper framework for assessing commercial and private lending offers as a borrower, read "Get a Second Opinion Before You Sign". It remains one of the few Australian books aimed at protecting borrowers in this space.

And if you want broader commentary from Shane St Reynolds on commercial issues, legal process and public-interest matters, you can also visit shanereynolds.com.au.

Need commercial or private finance? Start with the right questions

If you need a first or second mortgage, caveat loan, development finance, bridging loan or other commercial funding, start here: poseidonfinance.com.au.

For a borrower-focused guide before you sign, get the revised edition of "Get a Second Opinion Before You Sign".

If you want to discuss your matter directly, book a consultation at https://shanestreynolds.com/contact, email [email protected] or call 08 6263 6236.

commercial financebusiness loansPoseidon FinanceShane St ReynoldsAustralia

Share this article